First State Insurance

118 S Main St
Middlebury, IN 46540-0000

Phone: (574) 825-5458 | Fax: (574) 825-6158
Gregg Berry, VP

Map to First State Insurance

Middlebury residents can rely on First State Insurance to give a helping hand when making an insurance buying decision. Visit our location at 118 S Main St in Middlebury or call (574) 825-5458 to talk with a representative. Servicing Middlebury and the entire Elkhart county region.

Insurance Videos

Protecting your Home from Hail
Hail can be larger than five inches in diameter and rain down on your roof faster than an interstate speeder!

Find out if your Home is Underinsured
Don't wait until a disaster strikes to find out that you don't have enough coverage on your home.

Replacement Auto Parts
Are replacement parts as good as factory originals? Watch this video to find out!

How to File an Auto Insurance Claim
Follow these guidelines when filing a car insurance claim after an accident.

How to Avoid Buying a Flooded Car
Learn how to spot the signs of a flooded car before making the purchase.

From Our Insurance Blog

Find a Local Insurance Agent

Our database of insurance agents allows you to find a local agent quickly. Over 200,000 agents to choose from!

Insurance Resources

Every U.S. state has a government division that provides consumer information. To visit your state's website, choose your state below.