Edit / Delete Listing
Pfenninger Insurance Inc
1220 Broad St
New Castle, IN 47362-4509
Phone: (765) 529-6400 | Fax: (765) 529-4000
Steven E Pfenninger, Owner
Map to Pfenninger Insurance Inc
Pfenninger Insurance Inc is dedicated to protecting New Castle residents with professional guidance and professional service. Call (765) 529-6400 for risk-free insurance quotes or stop by at 1220 Broad St in New Castle. Servicing New Castle and the entire Henry county region.
Insurance Videos

Dropping certain coverages and getting all your entitled discounts can really add up!

Are you confused about whether or not your need to buy rental car insurance? Watch this video!

Black Mold is a hazardous home invader and this video shows you how to protect your home against mold.

Are replacement parts as good as factory originals? Watch this video to find out!

Hail can be larger than five inches in diameter and rain down on your roof faster than an interstate speeder!
From Our Insurance Blog
Find a Local Insurance Agent
Our database of insurance agents allows you to find a local agent quickly. Over 200,000 agents to choose from!
Insurance Resources
Every U.S. state has a government division that provides consumer information. To visit your state's website, choose your state below.